Student Veterans of America®
Student Veterans of America®  |  News
Student Veterans of America®
MySVA Login
About Us
Mission & Vision
History
Our Team
Work For SVA
Partners & Supporters
Financials
Chapters
Find A Chapter
Establish A Chapter
Chapter Guide
Introduction
Chapter Onboarding
Chapter Officers
Chapter Operations
Chapter Relationships
Chapter Programming
Chapter Communications
Chapter Marketing & Branding
Chapter Development
Update Chapter Contact Info
Alumni
Programs & Events
National Conference
9/11 Day of Service
The Leadership Institute
VFW-SVA Legislative Fellowship
Scholarships
Washington Week
Regional Summits
Student Resources
SVA Liaisons
Career Services Liaisons
Disability Services Liaisons
Diversity, Equity and Inclusion Liaisons
Policy Liaisons
Research
Featured Projects & Publications
Life Cycle Atlas
Veteran Opinion Survey
Financial Health Survey
Basic Needs Survey
SVA Census
NVEST
Million Records Project
Government Affairs
Campus Advocacy
Policy Suggestion Portal
Natural Disaster Map
In-State Tuition Map
Resident Tuition Overview
Career Center
Partner Directory
VMock
Veterati
Career Board
News
Give
Donate
SVA Store
Partner with SVA
SVA Ambassadors
Combined Federal Campaign (CFC)
Participate in Research
Donate
Contact
← Return to News

Court: Veterans with Multiple Periods of Service Entitled to Additional GI Bill Benefits

07/12/2021

What’s the issue? 

In the past, if a veteran chose to use Post-9/11 GI Bill benefits, they were required to waive the remainder of any Montgomery GI Bill (MGIB) benefits they had earned to prevent “double dipping.” After waiving their remaining MGIB benefits, the veteran was only entitled to Post-9/11 GI Bill benefits in the amount of their unused MGIB. 

An August 2019 court decision appeared to change this for some veterans by fundamentally altering how the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) administers these education benefits. Now, that decision has been affirmed by a court of appeals.  

The Facts 

The veteran in the case, Rudisill, served from 2000-2002, which qualified him for MGIB benefits. He used these benefits from 2003-2004. Rudisill served again from 2004-2005. Altogether, he used MGIB benefits from 2003-2007 for a total of 25 months and 14 days out of the 36 months for which he was eligible. Rudisill returned to active duty and served from 2007-2011. At this point, he became eligible for Post-9/11GI Bill benefits. He later sought to use his Post-9/11 GI Bill and appealed the VA’s decision which only approved him for those benefits in the amount of his remaining MGIB benefits, which was just slightly more than 10 months. 

The Arguments 

Rudisill argued he was eligible for full Post-9/11 GI Bill benefits, limited only by the overall 48-month cap on total education benefits. He claimed his multiple periods of service separately qualified him for full Post-9/11 GI Bill and MGIB benefits and that he should be allowed to use both. VA disagreed arguing the law required Rudisill to waive the remainder of his MGIB benefits in order to use his Post-9/11 GI Bill benefits. They further insisted, that upon waiving his benefits, Rudisill was only entitled to Post-9/11 GI Bill benefits in the amount of his remaining MGIB benefits. 

How the Courts Ruled 

On August 15, 2019, the United States Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims issued its opinion in the case ruling that a veteran with multiple periods of qualifying service could use both Post-9/11 GI Bill benefits and Montgomery GI Bill (MGIB) benefits up to each individual program’s 36-month cap, subject only to the 48-month cap on total benefits. 

The Court looked at the statutes, associated regulatory framework, congressional intent, and pro-veteran canon—a form of statutory interpretation calling for doubt to be resolved in a veteran’s favor. In the end, it determined the statute was best read to afford the veteran maximum benefits and flexibility in using those benefits. 

Specifically, the Court concluded that the law allows veterans with multiple periods of service to “receive entitlement under both programs subject to a 36-month cap on utilization of each of the two separate programs and a 48-month cap overall.” It further emphasized that for veterans with multiple periods of service the relevant “statutes require neither relinquishment nor exhaustion” of MGIB benefits prior to using Post-9/11 GI Bill benefits. 

VA appealed the decision, but on July 8, 2021, the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit issued an opinion confirming the lower court’s ruling.  

Updates

On February 3, 2022, the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit vacated the July 8, 2021 decision that upheld the lower court’s ruling. The Court granted VA’s request to rehear the appeal en banc.

The United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit reheard the case en banc before a panel of 12 judges. On December 15, 2022, the Court issued an opinion reversing the earlier decision that had granted additional VA education benefits to Rudisill and other similarly situated veterans. Two judges dissented. Attorneys for Rudisill indicate they will petition the Supreme Court to hear the case.

Last updated: January 23, 2023

This article is intended to serve as a summary of the legal proceedings discussed herein. The information conveyed above is specifically not intended as legal opinion or analysis and is not meant to serve as professional legal advice or counsel. If you need legal advice, opinion, analysis, or other assistance, you should contact a licensed attorney in the appropriate jurisdiction. 

Student Veterans of America Celebrates Introduction of VA Work-Study Legislation

Student Veterans of America Update on Post 9/11 GI Bill MHA Delayed Payment for March 2023

FourBlock Veteran Career Readiness Program Marketing Toolkit

Student Veterans of America Spring 2023 Newsletter

Advocacy

Tester, Boozman Bipartisan Bill Requires VA to Take a More Comprehensive Look at Veteran Suicide

Student Veterans of America Announces Formal Partnership with FourBlock 

Student Veterans of America Celebrates Major End-of-Year Policy Victories

Partners

Student Veterans of America 2023 NatCon Sponsor and Partner Recognition

Student Veterans of America Winter 2022 Newsletter

Advocacy

VA Delays New Enrollment Manager System to Reduce Impact on Student Veterans

Student Veterans of America Fall 2022 Newsletter

Federal Government Announces New Actions on Student Loan Debt

Student Veterans of America PACT Act Status Update

Advocacy

Student Veterans of America Presents Testimony on Pending Legislation Before the HVAC EO

Raytheon Missiles & Defense and Student Veterans of America Announce 2022 Patriot Scholarship Recipients

Advocacy

ED to Accept DD-214s in Certifying Military Service for Public Student Loan Forgiveness

Student Veterans of America Receives $8 Million Grant from MacKenzie Scott

Student Veterans of America Names Three Board Members, Including Current Student and Recent Graduate

Events

Watch the 2022 State of Student Veterans of America

Events

Student Veterans of America 2022 NatCon Honors Award Recipients

Events

Student Veterans of America Awards Inaugural Senator Bob Dole Continued Service Award to Global War on Terrorism Memorial Foundation

Events

Media Advisory: Student Veterans of America (SVA) 2022 National Conference

Advocacy

COVID-19 Protections Extended and Rounding Out Restored

Events

Student Veterans of America Honors: Meet our Finalists

COVID-19 Benefit Protections and Rounding Out: Updates for Student Veterans

Student Veterans of America NatCon 2022: Registration is Open!

What the New PSLF Changes Mean for Service Members and Veterans 

Student Veterans of America Joins MTV Entertainment’s Mental Health Youth Action Forum

Rutgers CMSI and Student Veterans of America Partner to Support Student Veterans at MSIs

Student Veterans of America Alumni Participates in Foreign Affairs Information Technology (FAIT) Fellowship

Student Veterans of America Joins Welcome.US

Comcast NBCUniversal and Student Veterans of America Announce 2021 Scholarship Recipients

Student Veterans of America Applications Open for 2022 VFW, SVA Legislative Fellowship

Current Events in Afghanistan: What can Chapter Leaders do to Help?  

Student Veterans of America Message to Our Community in Response to Current Events in Afghanistan

VHA Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DE&I) Listening Sessions for Veterans

Appropriations Brief: Department of Veterans Affairs and Department of Education  

The Bipartisan Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act

Student Veterans of America Announces 2021 Google Scholarship Recipients

Meet the Student Veterans of America Programs & Services Team

Court: Veterans with Multiple Periods of Service Entitled to Additional GI Bill Benefits

Events

Stay Engaged this Summer with Student Veterans of America Chapter Events

Refresh of Higher Education Regulations Announced

Student Veterans of America Names Two Board Members

What Revitalizing America’s Infrastructure Could Mean for Student Veterans 

Raytheon Missiles & Defense and Student Veterans of America Announce 2021 SPY-6 Scholarship Recipients

House Approves Several Student Veterans of America Policy Priorities

Partners

Veteran Wellness Alliance Offers Trusted Care Through Check-In

Student Veterans of America Joins First National Mental Health Action Day

Student Veterans of America Joins Vietnam War Commemorative Partners

Top Ten Takeaways: The American Rescue Plan Act of 2021

Events

Watch the 2021 State of Student Veterans of America

Events

2021 Student Veterans of America Honors Award Recipients

Events

The 2021 Student Veterans of America Honors Gala: Meet our Finalists

COVID-19 FAQs

What the CARES Act Means for Student Veterans, Service Members, and their Families

Events

Join Student Veterans of America for the National Day of Service

Advocacy, COVID-19

Final Bills of the 116th Congress

Advocacy, COVID-19

Major Veteran Legislation Clears Congress

Student Veterans of America Statement on VA Office of Inspector General Report

Events

Student Veterans of America NatCon Returns: February 19-20

Events

GVSU Announces Veteran Promise

Events

Student Veterans of America Debuts Public Service Announcement

Events

Jared Lyon Delivers Veterans Day Remarks

Events

How to Stream Veterans Day Events

#VOTE Like a Veteran

Events

Raytheon Missiles & Defense and Student Veterans of America Announce 2020 Patriot Scholarship Recipients

Events

Jared Lyon Named 2020 NYC Veterans Day Grand Marshal

Advocacy

Volunteer to Power The Polls

Advocacy, COVID-19

Pandemic Assistance for Student Veterans Act Introduced

Events

Veterans Day on Your Campus: Virtual Event Ideas

Events

Student Veterans of America Leadership Institute Applications Open

Advocacy

Moving Beyond Patchwork Systems: The Future of Education Services IT

Events

Student Veterans of America Regional Summit Starts on September 26th

Advocacy

Legislative Updates: Fall 2020

Research

Survey Finds 96% of Student Veterans Will Vote

Partners

Apply for the Raytheon Patriot Scholarship

Partners

Resources for Student Veterans During COVID-19

Events

Watch Home with the Brave: A Graduation Salute

SVA

1012 14th Street NW, 12th Floor
Washington D.C. 20005
Telephone: (202) 223-4710

About Us Our Team Chapters
Programs & Events Research Government Affairs
Career Center News Financials
Privacy Policy Terms of Use Donate
© 2023 Student Veterans of America® is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization.